| PETER J. D'ADAMO
Copyright 1989 Peter D'Adamo. All rights reserved.
Originally published in The Townsend Letter for Doctors, September 1990
Despite the recognized importance of the ABO, MNS, and Lewis antigens in blood typing, few physicians appreciate the extraordinary complexity of this system, its association with human disease, fascinating phylogenetic heritage and usefulness in describing physiologic parameters, especially digestive and secretory. These antigens are found in secretions throughout the body and on the surface of endothelial and epithelial cells.
The first description of a human blood group system was published by Landsteiner in 1900, working to understand the unpredictability of hemolytic reactions resulting from early attempts at transfusion. Using the newly discovered lectins abrin and ricin, recently isolated by Stillmark, he was able to describe classically what has still remained the major blood group of clinical interest. Many other blood grouping systems based either on membrane or sera antigen antibody interactions have also been discovered. The most clinically relevant of these are the MNS and Lewis antigen systems. It is estimated that there are in excess of 400 blood type antigens now known.
There are now set parameters which determine if an antigen possesses blood group activity. Most blood group antigens are carbohydrates extending outward from membrane bound glycolipids and glycoproteins. These membrane glyco conjugates are typically rich in sialic acids whose high degree of hydrophilicity and negative ionic charge results in their projection outward from the cell membrane. Sialic acids do not appear to have a role in ABO blood group specificity, but high or low concentrations may enhance or interfere with the expression of blood group activity.
The ABO and Lewis systems possess a common basic structure and their individual specificity is determined by the sequence and linkage of sugars at the end of the carbohydrate chains. It has been estimated that of the oligosaccharides projecting from the cell surface, 100 per 300,000 bear blood group antigenic determinants.
There are two types of backbone structures: Type I chains, which contain galactose linked 6-(1-3) to N-acetylglucosamine, and Type 2 chains where the linkage is 13-(1-4). Oligosaccharides with these terminal ends do not possess blood group specificity, but can and do cross react immunologically with many bacterial polysaccharides.
The ABO System
These antigens are synthesized from an oligosaccharide intermediate, H substance, which is produced by the presence of the monosaccharide fucose on either Type 1 or 2 chains. Group A or B activity is produced by the addition of a single sugar on the nonreducing end of H chain. The addition of this sugar markedly reduces the reactivity of the H substance. Adding the glycoprotein N-acetylgalactosamine to the end of the chain results in blood group A antigenicity, whereas with blood group B the terminal carbohydrate and B group antigen is the monosaccharide galactose. There is no O antigen: group O cells contain the H antigen, but the designation group H has been maintained for historical reasons. The terminal carbohydrate of O(H) antigen is the monosaccharide fucose.
ABH Secretor system
It was first shown by Lehrs in 1930 that some people do and others do not secrete into their saliva antigens corresponding to their ABO blood group. Sakes found that the abiliity to secrete behaved as a simple Mendelian function dominant to non-secretion. Group A, B, and AB persons who are secretors secrete the antigens corresponding to their blood groups. Group H persons who secrete the H substance, as do all other secretors; to a somewhat less extent. The secretor gene is identified as Sec to distinguish it from the Ss blood group.
The Lewis System
The ABH and Lewis glycoproteins possess a common basic structure and their blood group specificity is determined by the sequence and linkage. There are two Lewis antigens, termed Lea and Leb. The presence of fucose linked to C-4 of N-acetylglucosamine on a Type 1 chain results in Lea activity, but a Type 2 oligosaccharide containing fucose linked to C-3 of N-acetylglucosamine on a Type 2 chain results in very weak Lea activity. The appearance of a second fucose on a type one chain results in the appearance of a new antigenic determinant, Leb, and the loss of most H and Lea antigenicity. A Type 2 difucosyl chain has very weak Leb activity.
The MNS System
The genetics of the system seem to imply that the N antigen is actually a precursor substance and the N gene is an amorph which leaves the N antigen unchanged while the M gene of the heterozygote converts part of the N antigen into M, and in the homozygote converts nearly all of the precursor to M. The MN antigens seem to have a direct interaction with membrane bound sialic acids, as M and N specificities seem to be linked to the presence of sialic acid variations. It has been suggested that the antigenic variations may result from specific sialyl transferase activities, which transfer sialic acids to disaccharides bearing specific T and Tn specificities that characterize specific cryptic antigens. Mourant considers this blood group of interest only to the geneticist, due to a lack of disease association, however several diverse associations have surfaced including: an association of ankylosing spondylitis with homozygous MM (Sharon) and an association between heterozygous MN and homozygous NN with environmental induced hyperlipidemia (Martin). Cruz et. al. studied the tendency of Easter Islanders to become "hypertensive" upon moving to the mainland and concluded that homozygous NN was significantly more liable to develop hypertension. These are interesting disease associations, yet probably result more from co-dependent alleles than from a direct membrane bound antigen interaction.
Rh incompatibility is the major cause of hemolytic disease of the newborn, however very few searches have been made for any other kinds of disease associations of the Rh groups. Rh- status is largely a European gene (40%), with its highest frequency among the Basques of Spain, a remarkably homogenous group, originally late paleolithic or early mesolithic inhabitants of the Pyrenee Mountains. The U.S population is approximately 15% Rh- and 85% Rh+.
The Fya and Fyb antigens were discovered in the 1950's. Sanger discovered that a high percentage of African Negroes are of the phenotype Fy (a- b-), which is apparently a third gene termed Fyx which does not react with anti-Fya or anti Fyb. In 1975 Miller was able to show that this type is probably specifically resistant to Vivax malaria, to which Africans have long been known to be resistant.
The PI antigen is found in hydatid cyst fluid, and in a considerable variety of worm, both parasitic and free living. It is probably not uncommon that anti-P1 is not infrequently found in the sera of humans in response to worm infestation. The distribution of the p2 allele runs north to south and way from 180 degrees E. The highest frequencies reported by Blangero for the P2 allele are Circumpolar people, Oriental, and Pacific Islanders, people with a tradition of fish eating, reindeer and caribou hunting/ herding and aquatic mammal diets. Thus the high P2 allele may result from ensuing helminthiasis.
These antigen scarcely qualify as a blood grouping system. Anti-I antibodies are common, yet more common are anti-IH antibodies which is distinct from I or H but is presence on cells containing both. Anti-I is a cold agglutinin, so termed because its activity is enhanced at low temperature. This antibody is often seem in the serum of patients with infectious mononucleosis.
Other human genetic variations of clinical interest include: the ability to taste phenylthlocarbamide (associated with certain thyroid susceptibilities), ear wax types (associated with carcinoma of the breast), aryl hydrocarbon hydoxylase (lung cancer), the Group Specific Component globulins (vitamin D transport), protease inhibitors, protease inhibitors, G6PD and a variety of hemoglobins.
Paleoserology of the ABO Groups
Ottenberg first attempted ethnic classification based on blood groups. However the limited information available at that time made for strange bedfellows (including a "Hunan" group composed of Japanese, Southern Chinese, Hungarians and Rumanian Jews). It was not surprising that anthropologists took one look at the list, shuddered, and said, in effect, "No thanks; I'll take vanilla."
A more recent attempt by Lavory, who was aware that racial classification based merely on ABO groups would in many cases give results which would not fit well with older ideas about race. He also incorporated M and N types and occasional other blood factors to distinguish populations not clearly differentiated by A and B. He distinguished the following races: 1) Europeans (Nordics and Alpines of Europeans of the Near East); 2) Mediterranean; 3) Mongolian (Central Asia and Eurasia); 4) African (Blacks); 5) Indonesian; 6) American Indian; 7) Oceanic (including Japanese); 8) Australian (a sub variety of Oceanic). Lavory failed however to realize that the characteristics needed to define race, such as morphology or skin color are independent of each other.
Wiener has proposed the following racial classification, based largely on ABO and Rh factors: 1) Caucasoid group (highest incidence of Rh-, relatively high incidence of genes for Rh- and A2, moderately high incidence of all other types); 2) Negroid group (highest incidence of RhO, moderate frequency of Rh-, high relative incidence of genesA2 and the rare intermediate A and Rh genes); 3) Mongoloid group (virtual absence of Rh- gene and gene A2). Using MN data, he then further classified the Mongoloid group into an Asiatic group, a Pacific Island and Australian group, and a group including American Indians and Eskimos.
Group O is the blood type present as the overwhelming majority in 'ancient' or 'isolated' peoples. It is the only blood group that possesses two opposing antibodies, thus one would suppose this trait would convey some selctive advantage against microorganisms with A (and/or B) antigen mimicking properties, the population of microbes that constitutes the majority of common epidemic diseases.
It has been an often stated assertion that all full-blooded Amerindians are group O, Wyman and Boyd, in ingenious fashion, were able to blood type remains of early prehistoric Amerindian (Basket Maker and aboriginal) remains, finding sufficient group A to cast some doubt on this. Nonetheless, even recent studies on largely intermingled Amerindian populations shows a very (67-80%) predominance of group O, implying that their migration was perhaps earlier that previously thought, and most definitely seems to be a paucity of group B. Additionally, it has been shown that introduction of these genes into the population does result in mutation rates much higher than expected. Studies on Egyptian mummies shows the group B was fairly well distributed (if, as some have asserted, it comes from India) in Egypt at least 5,000 years ago. These serological variations in race apparently can not be explained simply by mutation; selection, migration and random genetic drift must also be accounted for.
Blood group A seems to have attained significant numbers only after group O, appearing during the lce Age (30,000 to 100,000 years ago), and perhaps representing an adaptation to cold. Its minor subtypes A-intermediate, Ax and A-Bantu seem to be adaptations to parasitic infection.
Group B would seem to have reached appreciable numbers last. Lewontin has conjectured that the complete absence of the gene in Amerindian and Australian aboriginal populations suggested that its origin would have occurred after the rise in sea levels that accompanied the melting of the continental glaciers, 10,000 years ago.
Group AB (a product of A and B parents) seems to be a recent phenomenon also. Studies on prehistoric grave exhumations in Hungary showed a distinct lack of this blood group into the Langobard age (4th to 7th century AD). Populations in Europe also seem to differ serologically from most other populations of the world, except perhaps the African. There !sat present time no other human (or anthropod) group with proportionally more A2 than the average European. This gene has been speculated to perhaps convey some disadvantage, which under more stringent selection in Asia was eliminated. In Paleolithic European man the gene, although perhaps inferior to A1, lingered on.
There is good evidence for considerable effects of selection on blood type distribution. Although most recent work has centered on malignant or degenerative disease associations between the ABO groups, infection undoubtedly accounted for the majority of natural selection in prehistoric populations. This can be explained by the phenomenon of "horror auto toxicus": i.e. the body has an inherent aversion to producing antibodies to self antigens. Thus group AB which produced no antibodies with either A or B specificity would be at selective disadvantage to organisms possessing either A or B antigenicity.
Livingstone has pointed out the inherent fault in a simple mutation theory of blood group distribution: Given the time frame, these mutations would have had to occur in humans at a rate four times faster than Drosophila!. However as will be seen, the effect of selection via infectious disease on small populations (with added random genetic shift) does explain the blood group variation in a far shorter time frame.
Infectious Disease Associations and ABO Group
Mourant was the first to hypothesize that the relatively high distribution of A in areas with historically high incidence of plague (Turkey, Greece, Italy) would point to selective disadvantage for group O, proven immunochemically by blood group studies on various Yersinia species. Antigenic similarity exists between the blood groups and a great variety of bacterial, rickettsial and helminthic species, including: typhoid, streptococci (group A), staphylococci (group O), Shigella and Proteus. Blood group A antigen is virtually identical with Pneumoccus polysaccharide antigen, which would suggest an association between group A and this organism, which indeed does exist. The generation of isoagglutinins via pneumoccocal vaccination was so great (fourfold) that the manufacturers advised doctors not to administer the vaccine to premenopausal women, fearing hemolytic difficulties in ABO incompatible pregnancies. Urinary tract infections have shown great ABO correlation. Ratner showed that anti-B agglutinogens provided greater protection against UTI than anti-A, and was able to demonstrate a significantly greater incidence of UTI from Pseudomonas, Kelbsielia and Proteus in group B. Group O which does produce anti-B, but in much lower titers than group A was, of allergic dermatosis and tropical eosinophilia show high group A frequencies. Damian gives many examples of blood group-like antigens in parasitic worms, especially of A and B-like ones such as Ascaris lumbricoides.
Other Blood Types
There is a general paucity of information on blood groups other than ABO. Paciokiewicz showed a general deficiency of Rh+ in mumps, infectious mononucleosis and viral meningitis. It is interestingly to note that viruses tend to attack the non-antigenic types of both the Rh and ABO systems (O and Rh-), respectively. Mourant mentions an association between granulomatous disease and the Kell system, which explains the recognized autosomal dominance noted with this syndrome.
Several studies imply that the development of isoagglutinins results from cross sensitization between bacterial polysaccharides and immature gut wall of the infant. One study shows a persistent sensitization of infant red cells resulting from E. Coli enteritis.
- Boyd WC. Genetics and the Races of Man. An Introduction to Modern Physical Anthropology. Little Brown and co. 1950.
- Brues AM. Tests of Blood Group Selection. Amer. J. Forensic Medicine 1929, 287-9
- Childe VG. Man Makes Himself Watts and Co. Publishers, London 1936
- Coon CS The Races of Europe MacMillan Co Publishers New York NY 1939
- Diamond J. Guns, Germs and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies WW Norton & Co. New York, Copyright 1997
- Gates RR. Human Ancestry Havard Univ Press Publishers Cambridge MA 1948
- Hirschfeld L and Hirschfeld H. Lancet 2; 675; 1919
- Livingston FR. Natural selection, disease and ongoing human evolution as illustrated by the ABO groups. Source unknown. Copy in authors possession
- Mourant AE, Kopec AC and Domaniewska-Sobczak K. Blood Groups and Disease 1984 Oxford Press, 4th edition.
- Mourant AE. Blood Relations; Blood Groups and Anthropology. Oxford Science Publications, Oxford University Press 1983
- Muschel L. Blood groups, disease and selection. Bacteriological Rev. 30(2) 1966; 427-41
- Race RR and Sanger R. Blood Groups in Man, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, 1975
- Sheppard PM. Blood groups and natural selection. Brit. Med. Bull. 15;132-9: 1959
- Soulsby EHL Antigen-antibody reactions in helminth infections. Adv. Immunol. 2: 265-308; 1962
- Snyder LH. Blood Grouping in Relation to Clinical and Legal Medicine. Williams and Wikin Publishers 1929
- McNeil WH. Plagues and Peoples Anchor Press Doubleday, Publishers New York NY 1975
- Wyman LC and Boyd WC. Blood group determinations of pre-historic American Indians. Amer. Anthropol. 39; 583-592: 1937
- Wyman LC and Boyd WC. Human blood groups and anthropology. Amer. Anthropol. 37; 181: 1935
- A geneticist maps ancient migrations, New York Times July 27, 1993
- Addi GJ Blood groups in acute rheumatism. Scottish Med. J. 4; 547, 1959
- An insight is gained on how ulcers develop. New York Times December 17, 1993
- Aird I et ai. Blood groups in relation to peptic uiceration and carcinoma of the breast, colon, bronchus and rectum. Br. Med. J. 315-42 Aug 7 1954.
- Allan TM and Dawson AA. ABO blood groups and ischemic heart disease in men. Brit Heart J. 30: 377-82 1968
- Billinngton BP. Note on the distribution of ABO blood groups in bronchiectasis and portal cirrhosis. Australian Ann. Med 5;20-22 1956
- Buchanan JA and Higley ET. The relationship of blood groups to disease. Brit, J. Exper. Pathol. 2; 247-253: 1921
- Buckwalter et aii. Ethnologic aspects of the ABO blood groups: disease associa-tions. JAMA 165: 327 1957
- Buckwalter et al. ABO Blood groups and disease. JAMA 1210-4. Nov 24 1956
- Camps FE and Dodd BE. Increase in the incidence of non-secretors of ABH blood group substannces among alcoholic patients. Brit Med J. I 30-31 1967
- Camps FE and Dodd BE. Frequencies of Secretors and Non-secretors of ABH group substances among 1000 alcoholic patients. Brit. Med J. (4) 1969 457-9
- DAdamo P and Zampieron E. Does ABO bias in natural immunity imply an innate difference in T-cell response J. Naturopath. Med. 2 11-17 1991
- DAdamo P. Blood types and diseases, a review. Clinical Rounds presentation, Bastyr University 1982
- Blood groups and succeptibilty to disease: a review. B. J. Prev. Soc. Med. 11: 107-25 1957
- Fraser Roberts JA. Some associations between blood types and disease. Brit. Med. Bulletin 15; 129-33 1959
- Harris R et al. Vaccina virus and human blood group A substance. Acta genetica 13: 44-57 1963
- Havlik R et al. Blood groups and coronary heart disease (letter). Lancet August 2 1969 269-70
- Hein OH et al. Alcohol consumption, Lewis phenotypes, and the risk of ischemic heart disease. Lancet Feb 13 1993 392-96
- Koskins LC et al. Degradation of blood group antigens in human colon ecosystems. J Clin. Invest. 57: 63-73; 1976
- Langman MJS et al. ABO and Lewis blood groups and serum cholesterol. Lancet September 20 1969 607-9
- Lim W et al. Association of secretor status and rheumatic fever in 106 families. Amer J. Epidemiology 82; 103-111 1965
- Martin NG et all. Do the MN and Jk systems influence environmental variability in serum lipid levels. Clinical Genetics 24; 1-14 1983
- McDuffie and Hart. The Behavior in the Coombs Test of Anti-A and Anti-B Produced By immunization with Various Blood Group Specific Substances and By Heterospecific Pregnancy. J. Immuno. 77; 61 -71 1956
- Myrianthopolous NC et al. Relation of blood groups and secretor factor to amyotrophic lateral schlerosis. Amer. J. Human Genet. 19; 607-616 1967
- McConnell RB et al. Blood groups in diabetes mellitis. Brit. Med. J. 1;772-776 1956
- Roath S, et al. Transient acquired blood group B antigen associated with diverticular bowel disease. Acta Hematologic 77: 188-90; 1987
- Ratner et al. ABO groups uropathogens and urinary tract infection. Amer.J. Med. Sci. 292: 84-92 1986
- Springer GF and Horton RE. Erythrocyte Sensitization by Blood Group Specific Bacterial Antigens. Journ. Gen. Physio 47: 1229-49 1964
- Springer GF. Relation of blood group active plant substances to human blood groups. Acta. Haem. 20: 147-55 1958
- Struthers D. ABO groups of infants and children dying in the west of Scotland (1949-51). Brit. J. Soc. Prev. Med. 5: 223-28 1951
- Wiener. Origin of naturally occuring hemagglutinins and hemolysins: a review. J. lmmunol. 66:287 1951
- Young VM, Gillem HG, Akeroyd JH. Sensitization of infant red ceiis by bacterial polysaccharides of E. coli during enteritis. Journ. Ped. 60: 172-6 1962
- Editorial. Blood groups and the intestine. Lancet 7475 December 3 1966
- Oh my aching stomach! Witby Republican. December 12 1993
Reviewed and revised on: 05/02/18